Band still has flood concerns

While the majority of city council voted to approve the SmartCentres development permit applications, concerns from the Neskonlith Indian Band about flooding have not been appeased.

While the majority of city council voted to approve the SmartCentres development permit applications, concerns from the Neskonlith Indian Band about flooding have not been appeased.

In a July 7 letter to the city, Chief Judy Wilson urged the city to not approve the Hazardous Areas Permit application until after meaningful consultation with the band had taken place.

Last month the Neskonlith provided a report to city council and staff from Dr. Michael Church, a professional engineer who specializes in fluvial geomorphology, or natural stream channel design. On July 5, Church reiterated his belief that “the proposed project presents significant issues of environmental integrity.”

The July 7 letter from Wilson to the city states: “Notwithstanding the Stantec response, Professor Church’s opinion remains that the flooding risk posed by the property and the potential impacts on neighbouring ecological values have not been properly assessed, and that further work is required. He continues to reject the conclusion of Stantec that this development is safe for its intended use and that there are no hazards which preclude the construction of the development.”

Stantec engineers provided a report for SmartCentres on flood hazard as well as responding on June 24 to Church’s report. Stantec concluded there will be no measurable increase in the current flood hazard risk to adjacent properties from the development.

Differences between the two engineering reports centered on differing calculations for flood level construction as well as the accuracy of the 200-year flood level.

Stantec’s June 24 reply to Church’s report states: “Dr. Church also theorizes that flood flows in the Salmon River are increasing due to three main factors (land use change, forest harvesting and beetle kill, and climate change) with changes in forest cover likely responsible for the majority of recent changes in the hydrology. Stantec had also made the same observation that change in forest cover may be affecting hydrology; however, this is a reversible condition as natural revegetation and reforestation occurs over the mid and long term.”

Church had noted that three of the four largest freshets on record for the Salmon River occurred in 1996, 1997 and 2008, and Stantec replied that none resulted in water levels approaching the recommended flood construction level. In a July 5 letter, Church stated that Stantec’s June 24 memorandum doesn’t change his opinion.

With regard to increasing flood flows, he stated: “The recent 20-year trend of rising flows in the river is dismissed by Stantec on grounds that events in the watershed, such as forest regrowth, must eventually reverse the effect. I regard this as an entirely irresponsible position to take.”


Just Posted

Brian Minter to share passion for gardens and greenspaces at Salmon Arm Fair

Well-known B.C. master gardener to give presentation on Friday, Sept. 6.

Rain in the forecast for much of the Southern Interior

Rain for much of the day in most areas clearing in the evening

Salmon Arm seniors enjoy the outdoors thanks to Rotary

Salmon Arm club fixes up and furnishes outdoor living spaces at Bastion Place

Salmon Arm Downtown Activity Centre owner wants to keep building alive

Support from community in form of tenants wanted for heritage building

Grass fire breaks out on highway south of Vernon

Highway 97 traffic slowed as firefighters snuff grass fire

Suspicious fire rips through abandoned Okanagan home

A fire was reported on Francescutti Court in Kelowna just after 1 a.m. Friday morning

Drugs, cash and 11 people apprehended at Okanagan residence

RCMP executed warrant at a Vernon home for second time in a month

Wildfire sparks beside Highway 3 west of Keremeos

A wildfire on the side of Highway 3 just west of Keremeos… Continue reading

Salmon Arm’s Hideaway Beer Badgers take semifinal win over Vernon’s OKG

Final goes Saturday in Vernon versus number-one seed N.E.T.

Summerland relaunches net metering program

Event open house will be held Aug. 27 from 3 to 6 p.m in Arena Banquet Room

Conan turns to the Property Brothers for tips on buying Greenland

Jonathan Scott suggests removing glaciers and mountains to bring in ‘more natural light’

Jaws of Life used to rescue driver in North Okanagan crash

Single-vehicle MVI causes traffic delays on Highway 6

Forests minister visits B.C. town rocked by multiple mill shutdowns

A third of Mackenzie turns out for rally, not much to cheer about

Most Read