Couple shocked by eviction notice for rural illegal suite

CSRD says zoning doesn’t permit residence to be used as rental duplex

The weather outlook just got quite a bit colder for a Silver Creek family.

Elizabeth and David Mark and their two dogs have been advised they have until April 1 to find another home after their landlord handed them an eviction notice as directed by the Columbia Shuswap Regional District.

Liz says when she and her husband moved into a rental “duplex” in July 2018, the Johnson Road property owners did not inform them the unit was an illegal suite.

A letter delivered by a CSRD bylaw officer to landlords Dave and Myrna Button on Feb. 22 spells out the issues.

The property, which is zoned ‘rural,’ permits a single-family dwelling, “which is occupied or intended to be occupied as a permanent home or residence of not more than one family.” As well, the bylaw does not allow a second set of cooking facilities or a recreation vehicle.

The Buttons were given seven days in which to provide confirmation of their intentions for rectifying the problem to the CSRD, after which the CSRD threatened legal action.

CSRD Planning Services Team Leader Corey Paiement says the issue is one of zoning and that the Buttons were the subject of bylaw enforcement for the same non-compliance issue in 2016.

“I think it’s unfortunate the property owner put them (renters) in this situation; he knew he was non-compliant,” says Paiement.

Read more: CSRD seeks court injunction

Read more: CSRD unveils new web presence

Shocked to be told they have one month to find another home, Liz says that while they have excellent references and long-term employment, their housing challenge is further complicated by their two English mastiffs.

Liz took her concern online to Salmon Arm Rant & Rave (Facebook) where she is also seeking a one or two-bedroom place in Salmon Arm, Armstrong or Vernon.

“(We are) really pissed off, when facing an extreme housing shortage, that government bodies are willing to shut down very nice, very well-built accommodations, showing no willingness to work with the owners to rectify the problems,” she writes.

“If there are no safety contraventions to a dwelling, why is the heavy-handed enforcement of the literal CSRD law necessary?” adds Dave Button in a Feb. 27 email to the Observer, noting he has recently made $31,000 in improvements to protect the building from flooding from Salmon River. “The CSRD is not there to provide housing and should possibly be aware that if best intentions between landlord and tenant are being met, then what good or what risk was prevented by the CSRD forcing an occupant to vacate a sound, well constructed dwelling?”

While the property owners will now face the cost of removing the second kitchen, they can apply to the CSRD to change the zoning. But that will take time and come at a cost.

As well as a $1,500 application fee payable to the regional district, Button would need an engineering report confirming adequate water and septic services and would have to put up a proposed development sign. The matter would then go to the board for first and second reading, with the usual public process to follow.

“The second part is that the property is located in the Agricultural Land Reserve so ALR approval would be needed as well,” says Paiement, acknowledging the current tight housing market. “We’re empathetic and if they need additional time, we might consider it, but not for an extended period of time.”


@SalmonArm
barb.brouwer@saobserver.net

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Salmon Arm RCMP recover stolen property near Lyman Hill

One person arrested, officers appear to be searching side of Highway 1

Salmon Arm to hold two peaceful protests in solidarity with Black Lives Matter

June 4 and 6 protests to fight for justice for victims of police brutality, against systemic racism

Vehicle stolen in Revelstoke recovered near Salmon Arm after occupants suffer overdoses

Police say they were alerted to the vehicle after occupants treated by ambulance after drug use

Transport truck driver walks away from crash where cab detaches from trailer

Driver won’t be charged regarding incident near Pritchard

Sicamous RCMP catch driver going twice the speed limit

The car was impounded for seven days and the driver received a hefty fine

WATCH: North Okanagan golf cart stolen, then returned

Homeowners have footage of two men taking the cart and then bringing it back

Police watchdog investigating fatal crash in Kelowna

Kelowna RCMP received a report of a single-vehicle collision on Bulman Road near Highway 97 on June 1

Kelowna council greenlights ‘The Wedge’

The wedge-shaped building will be built at the corner of Leon Avenue and Water Street

Province looks to seize Kelowna home owned by alleged drug trafficker

Michelle Collins and Nigel Byrne were also recently investigated by Kelowna RCMP for drug trafficking

22 new COVID-19 test-positives, one death following days of low case counts in B.C.

Health officials urged British Columbians to ‘stand together while staying apart’

John Horgan says COVID-19 restrictions won’t be eased regionally

B.C. Liberals urge ‘tailored’ response based on infections

Highway 1 closed after body found near Hope

Coroners Service reportedly on the scene, highway has been closed for 10 hours in both directions

Feds get failing grade for lack of action plan on anniversary of MMIWG report

‘Instead of a National Action Plan, we have been left with a Lack-of-Action Plan’

Most Read