Lawsuit on hold

A lawsuit launched by four companies affiliated with the SmartCentres shopping centre in Salmon Arm is on hold.

A lawsuit launched by four companies affiliated with the SmartCentres shopping centre in Salmon Arm is on hold.

In December of last year, a judge ruled that a lawsuit launched by SmartCentres Inc., Salmon Arm Shopping Centres Limited, Calloway Reit (Salmon Arm) Inc., and a B.C. numbered company against EBA Engineering Consultants Ltd. and three of its employees should proceed to a full trial. The defendants had applied for a summary trial – an expedited judicial process. A date of July 13 was set.

The lawsuit centres on the properties which are now the site of the SmartCentres shopping centre, anchored by the Walmart store. The plaintiffs state, in court documents, that they relied on  two EBA reports when they purchased the properties and they say the reports were prepared negligently by the defendants.

The properties were subject to provincial regulations governing setbacks to fish-bearing waters. EBA provided two reports, a preliminary environmental investigations report on Feb. 22, 2007 and a preliminary riparian area regulation assessment on July 30, 2007.

SmartCentres completed purchase of the land on Oct. 15, 2007 for $14.7 million.

The plaintiffs stated the two reports suggested that substantial portions of the properties could be used for development based on the setbacks from the riparian areas suggested. However, they say, the high water mark of Shuswap Lake impinges on the properties so much that only a portion of the land could be used for redevelopment. The plaintiffs say they suffered a loss of at least $3.3 million, and perhaps much more, as a result of their reliance on the EBA reports.

The defendants have put forward several defences, which include: they were not negligent in preparing the reports; the company did not breach its contractual obligations; and any loss suffered by the plaintiffs was caused by their own negligence or their failure to mitigate.

Although a trial date was set for 10 days beginning July 13 of this year, court records show that the trial has been adjourned. The court registry had no information on when the trial might be re-scheduled, and neither the lawyer for the plaintiffs nor the lawyer for the defence could be contacted.


Just Posted

Shuswap Middle School requests city’s help in resurfacing sports courts

Total cost estimated at $43,000, school would like 50 per cent contribution

Warm winter clothes wanted for Women Who Wine, Downtown Salmon Arm initiative

Clothing for Community event on Oct. 29 to support Lighthouse Shelter, SAFE Society, CMHA

North-Okanagan Shuswap candidates spending little on Facebook

Social media platform posts what federal parties have paid to advertise

Non-compliant buoys to be removed from Shuswap, Mara lakes

Transport Canada enforcement action to occur Oct. 21 to 25

Coalition talk at Okanagan College candidates forum

Vernon Students’ Association hosts forum to discuss important youth issues, minority government

Competition shakes up for the Okanagan Mixoff

The Okanagan Mixoff takes place Nov. 7 in Kelowna

Woman, 24, faces life-altering injuries after being dragged 4 blocks by vehicle in Vancouver

A gofundme account says the woman will have to undergo multiple complex surgeries

Fatal overdoses down by 33% in B.C., but carfentanil deaths continue to spike

Carfentanil, an illicit drug more powerful than fentanyl, causing more deaths than ever

South Okanagan dangerous offender guilty plea struck down

Trial delayed again because Ronald Teneycke failed to elect his choice of trial

Six bears destroyed in three days in West Kelowna

A West Kelowna business has been charged for leaving garbage around Lake Okanagan Resort

West Kelowna Warriors being sold back to BC Hockey League

Current owner Kim Dobranski said the sale back to the BCHL should be completed by the end of October

Police standoff ends peacefully in West Kelowna

A distraught man was taken into custody Wednesday afternoon

Most Read