On May 14, 2019, a jury found Samule McIntosh guilty of aggravated assault and assault with a weapon. (Photo: Samuel McIntosh)

North Okanagan man convicted of 2 stabbings yet to be sentenced

Samule McIntosh had his hearing adjourned Friday as counsel gets more medical information

A Vernon man found guilty of stabbing two brothers in the neck with a knife was expected to be handed his sentence Friday, but the hearing was adjourned due to a lack of medical records of the offender.

Samule McIntosh was found guilty by a jury on May 14, 2019 of aggravated assault and assault with a weapon. The charges stem from an incident on Aug. 28, 2016, when McIntosh stabbed Dayton Martens during an altercation near the now demolished Civic Arena in downtown Vernon and his brother, Dakota Martens, shortly after. McIntosh was homeless at the time.

Defence lawyer Ray Dieno submitted to Justice Murray Blok that a medical report for McIntosh, who is in a wheelchair, would be needed in order to weigh the physical toll he would endure in jail before a sentence length could be fairly determined.

With much reluctance and regret at this left turn in the daylong proceedings, Justice Blok ultimately agreed.

“The very unfortunate result is that I conclude that I do not have the information I feel I need to properly assess Mr. McIntosh’s circumstances,” he said.

“I say that with great regret,” Justice Blok continued. “This is far from an ideal manner in which to (handle) any case, let alone a case of such seriousness.”

READ MORE: Vernon man arrested with meat cleaver pleads not guilty to cop assault

READ MORE: Alleged drunk driver behind wheel of 18-wheeler fuel truck arrested in Nanaimo

McIntosh stabbed Dayton in the neck area and subsequently stabbed his brother Dakota in a similar area in what the Crown is calling two separate incidents. McIntosh has previously admitted to both stabbings.

“Dayton’s injuries were very serious and life-threatening,” said McPheeters. “The main wound ran from the base of his skull to his upper back, 15 centimetres in length and gaping open 10 centimetres. It was also four centimetres deep.”

The wound was so deep that it exposed the bones of Dayton’s spine, and the attending physician said he would have bled to death if not for the medical attention he received. Dayton also suffered two other less severe wounds. Dakota suffered one wound that was less severe than his brother’s.

McIntosh said he stabbed the brothers out of self-defence after having been provoked. Neither Crown nor defence have been able to agree on the precise details of the events.

The Crown has asked for three-and-a-half to four years in jail and a lifetime prohibition on owning weapons.

McIntosh — who appeared at the Vernon Law Courts an hour late after sleeping in — was struck by a car in November 2017 that has left him in a wheelchair. His injury is the basis for the defence’s argument that his medical condition needs to be weighed in the sentencing.

McPheeters argued an adjournment had already taken place in August for “the express purpose of obtaining medical information.”

“It appears it’s at least possible he’s putting off going to jail,” she said of McIntosh, who was told by his defence to seek a medical report.

McPheeters said she opposed but “understands” the decision to adjourn once more.

Justice Blok left it to the defence to sort out who will provide the medical report of McIntosh and who will pay for it. Dieno said McIntosh has struggled to find a family doctor who could conduct such a report. Justice Blok later wondered if McIntosh’s physiotherapist couldn’t be used for the purpose, or any of the physicians who attended to him after his car accident.

McIntosh has 89 days of jail time to his credit for time spent in custody, according to McPheeters.

A date for the sentencing will be fixed on Nov. 18. Justice Blok requested a two-day hearing for the remainder of the sentencing.


Brendan Shykora
Reporter, Vernon Morning Star
Email me at Brendan.Shykora@vernonmorningstar.com
Follow us: Facebook | Twitter

Just Posted

People who are homeless in Salmon Arm provide consultants with key information

Urban Matters consultants gather information from ‘experts’ as they work on housing strategy

Word on the street: What is your strategy for not spending too much on Christmas gifts this year?

The Observer asked: What is your strategy for not spending too much on Christmas gifts this year?

Map points to mysterious ‘Waterdome’ in the middle of Salmon Arm Bay

City would like to have map marker removed, pilot recalls its significance

43-acre property donated in memory of Shuswap man

Land along Eagle River to be named Ken Ritchie Park

Ski with Santa fundraiser and beginner trail opening coming to Larch Hills

Tour of new trail to take place on Dec. 28, followed by annual Lantern Ski

VIDEO: Boys help rescue Cariboo bear cub

The cub, weighing just 24lbs, has been taken to wildlife sanctuary in Northwest B.C. for the winter

Campbell River mom’s iPhone containing priceless photos stolen from Victoria hospital parkade

The phone contained photos, heartbeat recordings of her late son

Miller nets winner as Canucks edge Sabres 6-5 in OT

Roussel, Leivo tally two apiece for Vancouver

‘Norovirus-like’ outbreak interrupts Bantam hockey showcase in Greater Victoria

Several athletes were sent home, quarantined on the ferry

South Okanagan volunteer dental clinic donates rotten teeth to good cause

H.E.C.K. recently gifted 47 rotten teeth to a search and rescue group in the area

$578: that’s how much your first distracted driving ticket will cost with recent premium hikes

Over 50 per cent of Canadians admitted to using phone while driving last year, according to study

Healing with honesty: Justice served 40 years later

Revelstoke senior gets house arrest for sexually assaulting stepdaughter

WorkSafe BC to investigate explosion at Princeton facility

Explosion at Envirogreen waste reclamation plant occurred Nov. 27

Doors open to Vernon’s first refill store

Vernon’s Refill Store may be answer to plastics problem

Most Read