Is Gaza another pre-election war?

Global columnist Gwynne Dyer examines the latest developments in the conflict between Israel and Gaza.

Let’s be fair — there does seem to be some sort of pattern here, but it is not very consistent.

Five times in Israel since 1980, a right-wing government has called an election without launching a complementary military operation. The right lost two of those elections outright (1992, 1999), more or less tied two others (1984, 1988) and won only one of them decisively (2006).

On the other hand, critics of Israel point out, three times since 1980, right-wing Israeli governments have combined an election campaign with a major military operation against some Arab or Palestinian target. This combination, it has been argued, yields decisive electoral success for the right.

Menachem Begin’s government won the 1981 election three weeks after carrying out a dramatic attack on the Osirak research nuclear reactor that France had sold to Iraq.

In the view of most outside observers, the reactor, which was closely supervised both by the French and by the International Atomic Energy Agency, was not suited to the large-scale production of enriched uranium and posed no threat to Israel, but the attack was popular in Israel.

Ehud Olmert’s coalition launched the Cast Lead onslaught against the Gaza Strip in December 2008 and January 2009. The three-week campaign of massive bombardments and some ground incursions left 1,400 Palestinians and 13 Israelis dead. The election was held a month later and Binyamin Netanyahu emerged as the leader of a new right-wing coalition.

Son here we go again, perhaps?

Netanyahu is still the prime minister and the next elections are due in January. What better way to ensure success than to go and bash the Palestinians again?

A week later, with 86 Palestinians and three Israelis dead, his re-election is assured as Israelis overwhelmingly support the current military operation.

That’s the case that is made against Israel.

Does it hold water? Well, actually, it doesn’t.

Begin’s attack on the Osirak reactor in 1981 may well have been an electoral stunt, although he was clearly paranoid about the possibility of a nuclear weapon in Arab hands.

But, Ehud Olmert, though undoubtedly a man of the right, was not leading a right-wing government in 2008. He was the leader of a new centrist party, Kadima, that had been formed by defectors from both the right-wing Likud Party and left-wing Labour.

Moreover, Olmert had already resigned in mid-2008 over a corruption scandal and was merely acting as interim prime minister by the time the Cast Lead operation was launched in December of that year.

If it was an electoral ploy despite all that, it didn’t work. It was the right that actually won the election in early 2009 and formed a government led by the Likud Party’s Netanyahu.

It is equally hard to believe Netanyahu is seeking electoral gain by attacking Gaza this month. Every opinion poll in Israel for months past has been saying that he is going to win the January election hands down. For him, all the risk of Operation Pillar of Defence is on the downside — a major loss of Israeli lives in the campaign, while unlikely, could only work against him.

So, why is this happening now? Historians traditionally split into two camps: Those who see purpose and planning and plots behind every event and those who think most events are just the random interaction of conflicting strategies, imperfect information and human frailty.

This latter approach is known in the historical trade as the “cock-up theory of history” and it is very attractive as an explanation for the current situation.

Netanyahu, cruising home to an easy electoral victory in January, had absolutely no need for a little war with the Palestinians. Indeed, his strategy of continuously shouting “wolf” about Iran and its alleged nuclear weapons program has succeeded in distracting international attention from the Palestinians, leaving him free to expand Jewish settlement in the occupied West Bank unhindered.

Similarly, the Hamas leaders who rule Gaza had no interest in triggering a military conflict with Israel. They had every reason to believe the sweeping political changes in the Arab world were strengthening their position internationally and they had no need to remind Arabs of their plight.

So, how did this idiocy happen? Another cock-up, of course.

Hamas has been trying to maintain calm in Gaza and extend a ceasefire agreement with Israel, but it has little control over various radical jihadi groups who build popular support by making utterly futile rocket attacks on Israel.

Even if they kill a few Israelis, so what? How does that serve the cause?

Hamas faces the permanent political danger of being outflanked by more extremist rivals, so it cannot crack down too hard on the jihadis.

Israel, fed up with their pinprick attacks, was looking for somebody to punish and, since it couldn’t locate all the jihadi leaders, it decided to assassinate Ahmed al-Jabari, the head of the military wing of Hamas — even though that was bound to end the ceasefire.

So, Hamas then fired a few of its own rockets into Israel and Israel retaliated massively and we were off to the races once again. A complete cock-up and a pointless waste of lives.

But, since the mini-war doesn’t really serve the purposes of any major player, it will probably be shut down again fairly soon.

 

 

 

 

-Gwynne Dyer is an independent journalist whose columns appear in publications in 45 countries.

 

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

RCMP report that suspect in North Shuswap threatened to kill neighbours

Police say man was arrested with loaded weapons inside vehicle and residence

High water levels on Shuswap Lake may close popular Canoe Beach

Salmon Arm city staff say rain predicted could flood tunnel, causing beach closure

Sandbagging continues for flood-prone areas around Shuswap, Mara lakes

Shuswap Emergency Program closely monitoring water levels

B.C. Hockey League prepping for 2020-21

League reviewing different scenarios and start times in compliance with provincial regulations

Shuswap caregiver a hero in husband’s eyes

Night and day shifts leave little time for Tracy and Rick Duncan

VIDEO: A Vancouver Island black bear takes weekend nap in eagle tree

Videos captured by Terry Eissfeldt shows the bear arriving Saturday night and sleeping in on Sunday

189 homes in Grand Forks area given evacuation orders

Homes are in the Nursery, Grand Forks Airport, Gilpin Rd., Johnson Flats and Granby Rd. areas

Summerland man rescued following ATV accident

Helicopters used to transport injured man to Kelowna for treatment

Mother bear and two cubs spotted in West Kelowna

Residents of Shannon Lake are urged to be on the look out for three bears in the area

Social justice advocate yells at Kelowna council, demands presence at Black Lives Matter rally

Heather Friesen has again taken to council chambers to make her opinion heard

Youth filmmakers tackle technology addiction, relationships, cyber-bullying

The Kelowna couple won a grant from Telus STORYHIVE

Vernon videographer captures thunderstorm

See the ‘best bits’ of Saturday’s storm

Dyer: I left my heart in the desert

Kristy Dyer is a columnist for Black Press Media who writes about the environment

Most Read