Selfishness enters debate

For 14 years I owned and loved a dog. I sympathize with dog walkers.

For 14 years I owned and loved a dog. I sympathize with dog walkers. But media buzz exhorting the city to permit dogs on the foreshore trail through the nature preserve is too perfect a microcosm of a fundamental flaw in our culture: an almost totally human-centered selfishness and its inability to respect and protect nature for its own sake. Whenever possible, we should try to just let nature be, not endlessly use, abuse and degrade it through our delusion of ‘Dominion’ and ownership.

Deadly consequences of this human-entitlement belief include run-away degradation of Earth’s ecosystems in the atmosphere (pollution and climate-change), on land (deforestation and desertification), in water-bodies (think Montreal sewage or the oceans’ vast plastic-ridden ‘dead-zones’) and crashing world-wide biodiversity as natural wildlife habitats and their species are extinguished by our insatiable, dubious needs.

Only a mindset believing we’re separate from nature – except to ravage it as an unlimited resource as its self-styled, superior ‘owners’ – could explain our ongoing, disastrous cultural behaviour.

The foreshore dog-access issue confirms this self-centered cultural mind-set with startling clarity.

Ask yourselves, why can’t the foreshore and its wildlife be left alone?

And with so many alternative areas for canine-recreation, how can the focus of dog-owners be so insensitive?

I wonder what aspects of canine behaviour ‘inclusive-trail’ dog-owners don’t understand?

Like their predator relatives, dogs physiologically “mark” their surroundings, and this chemical marking carries with it olfactory signals of a potential predator’s presence. Obviously, such signals adversely affect wildlife !

Invoking canine behaviour certainly isn’t necessary to justify dog-exclusion from one tiny part of the Shuswap. The true cultural culprit is our ethically-flawed dismissal of natural foreshore values for the sake of our own exclusively human ones.

Tom Crowley


Just Posted

Kayaks, paddleboards stolen from tenants at Shuswap resort

Thefts reported to have occurred overnight on Wednesday, Aug. 14

In Photos: Sunday acts cap off Roots and Blues

Last day of the 2019 festival goes off under sunny skies

Update: Firetrucks off of Alexander Street, faulty air conditioning unit to blame

Occupants of downtown Salmon Arm building safe, back inside structure

Musicians wanted to play adventurous travellers along yellow brick road

Shuswap Theatre looking for artists to provide musical accompaniment for The Wizard of Oz

Sicamous RCMP arrest Lake Country man following truck break-in

Suspect found in possesion of bear spray, masks and break-in tools.

VIDEO: Canadian zoos’ captive breeding programs help preserve endangered species

Programs considered last-ditch effort to prevent local extinctions of turtles, butterflies and more

Kelowna International Airport threat deemed non-credible

Normal operations have resumed following note of a suspicious item on board a WestJet plane

Okanagan bus driver assaulted for asking patron not to smoke at stop

59-year-old in hospital with non-life threatening injuries

B.C. sets rules for ride hailing, same minimum fee as taxis

Larger operating areas seen as threat by cab companies

Two hiking families team up to extinguish fire in B.C. backcountry

Children and their parents worked for three hours to ensure safety of the popular hiking region

Salmon Arm history in pictures: RW Bruhn birthday

When people really partied! Guests of R.W. Bruhn at his summer cottage… Continue reading

Okanagan’s alleged “Deadpool” robber revealed

RCMP catch up with suspect following gas station robbery earlier this month

RCMP searching for missing Kelowna hitchhiker

Cody Kolodychuk was last heard from on July 31 and was thought to be hitchhiking in the Vernon area

Most Read