Letter: Shuswap MLA’s arithmetic flawed on proportional representation

Current Shuswap MLA Greg Kyllo has weighed in again on proportional representation, the vote counting system that gives fairer outcomes and results in an overwhelming majority of voters being represented in the legislature.

Mr. Kyllo is known for his peculiar Nov. 27/17 tweet in which he called the NDP government “illegitimate,” and the current referendum a “power grab” by the Green Party – which, he omitted to mention, received a substantial 332,387 votes (17 per cent) in the 2017 election.

Combined with the 795,106 votes given to the NDP, that makes a total of 1,127,493 votes. Compare this to the BC Liberal Party’s 796,672 votes – a mere 1,500+ votes more than the NDP, and 330,821 fewer than the combined NDP/Green Party voters’ mandate.

The NDP and Greens have actually formed a true majority government – a rarity under first-past-the-post, where typically 40 per cent or fewer votes wins all the political power.

Letter: Anderson condemns Kyllo’s comments

Governments in countries using proportional voting systems always elect governments that represent a majority of voters; in countries with first-past-the-post, this is the exception.

Mr. Kyllo has a special affection for the Koch Brothers-supported, corporation-friendly Fraser Institute.

He states the Fraser Institute says governments under proportional representation spend 24.3 per cent more than governments using the current system. But what the Fraser Institute actually says (not surprisingly, in the middle of the referendum campaign) is that governments in countries with proportional systems spend 6.6 per cent more than countries with our current system in absolute terms (a more real-world measurement).

And they spend that on social and environmental programs, for which Mr. Kyllo’s government has very little respect.

I trust Mr. Kyllo will use arithmetic more accurately when he makes future pronouncements.

I think it’s high time we opted for a proportional vote-counting system, where the number of seats truly reflects actual voter support.

Warren Bell

Just Posted

Preserving Secwepemc culture, history through storytelling

Neskonlith councillor Louis Thomas to share his craft at Word on the Lake

Targeted: Shuswap society finds pets hurt, killed in domestic abuse cases

SPCA, SAFE Society working together to provide shelter for dogs, cats of women fleeing abuse

Sicamous schools to receive cooling/heating upgrades

School District #83 capital budget bylaw includes more than $1.2 million for projects

Shuswap residents taking treated sludge protest to Kamloops

Opponents to proposed use of biosolids at Turtle Valley ranch will air concerns at city hall

FOODIE FRIDAY: Brodo Kitchen makes special poutine

Brodo Kitchen features homemade comfort food and a spin on Gnocchi, transformed into poutine

Truck crashed and dumped near Predator Ridge

Police are looking for two men in connection with a stolen vehicle

Snapshot: Twin day at Parkview Elementary

Visitors to Sicamous school were seeing double on April 18

Man seriously injured after driving wrong way down B.C. highway

Police say the driver hit a transport truck, then another car after merging from the off-ramp onto highway

Candidates ready for Summerland Blossom Pageant

Royalty pageant will be held at Centre Stage Theatre on May 3 and 4

Salt and Brick chef to compete in Canada’s Great Kitchen Party

Chef James Holmes will compete in the fall competition

Should B.C. lower speed limits on side roads to 30 km/h?

Vancouver city councillor wants to decrease speed limits along neighbourhood side roads

Give Canada geese at Okanagan beaches a break

LETTER: Tour busses, full of photographers, local goose guides and an annual goose festival

Lawsuit eyed over union-only raise for B.C. community care workers

‘Low-wage redress’ leaves 17,000 employees out, employers say

Most Read