Close vote from Salmon Arm council upholds 2021 termination of Canoe Beach lease lots

A tie vote defeats move by three council members to search for a ‘win-win’ solution

Cabins at Canoe Beach, located on publicly owned land, are to be removed when their leases are terminated in 2021. (File photo)

In a vote that could not have been closer, city council upheld its 2016 decision to terminate the lease lots at Canoe Beach in 2021.

At the Aug. 12 council meeting, with six of seven members present (Coun. Louise Wallace Richmond was absent), the mayor and two councillors voted for council taking another look at the plan to terminate the leases in October 2021, while three councillors voted against the motion and for the status quo. The 2016 decision also stipulates that the lessees of the 28 lots, each a portion of one city-owned lot, remove their waterfront cabins by that time.

The tie vote Monday meant the motion failed, so there will be no change to the 2016 agreement.

Voting for another look at the decision were Mayor Alan Harrison and Couns. Kevin Flynn and Sylvia Lindgren. Voting against were Couns. Tim Lavery, Debbie Cannon and Chad Eliason.

During the sometimes tense discussions, Flynn acknowledged he was part of the 2016 council that unanimously supported the lease expiration plan for 2021. However, he said he’s not sure now if the city has the budget or plans to take over the land at that time.

He said perhaps the takeover could be phased in; that way the city wouldn’t be losing revenue from the leases without having the means to do something with the vacated beach.

Read more: Salmon Arm Council approves five-year extension

Read more: Salmon Arm council to revisit city lease of Canoe Beach cabin lots

Rob Niewenhuizen, director of engineering and public works, was asked about the cost of making the beach usable for the public.

He said if the city were to acquire the land with the lots cleared, it would entail installing a porta potty or outhouse for about $40,000, rough seeding a picnic area for approximately $20,000 and possibly paving a roadway halfway up the length of the property as it narrows at one end. He estimated the total cost would be between $50,000 and $100,000.

Harrison also changed his view from 2016, suggesting a small committee of himself, another councillor, a staff member and one or two of the lessees meet to see if a win-win plan for the taxpayers and the lessees could be reached. He said the city’s Canoe Beach Master Plan includes upgrading Canoe Beach, which needs a lot of work and could take five years.

Lindgren stated she might be the ideal counsellor to be on that committee, given that she’s new to council and has no history with the issue. She also said such a committee might buy some goodwill if, as one councillor mentioned, a lessee had said they might not remove the buildings from the property.

Lavery said he fully supports the direction council took in 2016 of returning a public amenity to the public.

He said it’s not that he doesn’t give weight to the wishes of the lessees, but there was complete clarity to the 2016 agreement, with a good faith gesture from the city of increasing the final lease period to five years and not increasing the fees.

Read more: City council back to the beach lots at Canoe

Read more: 2015 – City initiates planning process for Canoe Beach, Klahani Park

Read more: 2016 – Have your say on Canoe Beach

Cannon said the lease lots were a big issue when the official community plan was revised 13 years ago. She said she’s seen how much staff time has been taken up by them – by some lessees not paying, with litigation, with having to remove buildings – even if it has been caused by a few ‘bad apples.’

She said the total amount spent on legal fees “would be staggering.”

“A decision was made in 2016. I don’t think we should go back on it.”

A letter given to the lessees in 2016 stated: “Council’s decision aligns with both the City of Salmon Arm Official Community Plan, which designates that this area will be returned to parkland, and the Canoe Beach Master Plan, which envisions the area as an extension of the public beach.”

Eliason pointed to the Canoe Beach Master Plan, noting it arrived from a lot of public consultation. He asked if council’s plan is now to get a group of six people to revisit it. Harrison replied that the timing would be revisited, not the plan.

Eliason stated there was a lot of discussion in 2014 and 2015 leading up to the 2016 decision. He emphasized there’s been lots of legal work, lots of litigation and the final five-year term was a compromise that was voted on unanimously.


@SalmonArm
marthawickett@saobserver.net

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter

Just Posted

Year-round training envisioned for Salmon Arm’s Rapattack base

Mayor hopes council’s support of Rapattack will pay off in longevity for base

Letter: Better fix needed than what’s proposed for Balmoral Road/Highway 1 intersection

Province already behind on widening of Trans-Canada Highway

Salmon Arm approved for worker based in Vernon to support homeless

While application to Ministry of Social Development gets nod, one to BC Housing denied

Column: Potentially valuable WorkSafeBC review let down by bias

Notes from the Legislature by Shuswap MLA Greg Kyllo

Boil water notice rescinded for Yard Creek Campground

Interior Health water testing shows acceptable levels of bacteria

Trudeau to meet with U.K. and Japanese prime ministers ahead of G7 summit

French President Emmanuel Macron, this year’s G7 host, has little expectations of a unified front from the leaders

Okanagan Nation bringing overdose awareness to Syilx Okanagan communities

The Purple Ribbon Campaign for International Overdose Awareness Day is Aug. 28

Groups ready campaign to help young voters identify ‘fake news’ in election

The media literacy campaign to focus on identifying misinformation and suspicious sources online

Big rally in northern B.C. draws attention to continuing lumber crisis

Mayor Joan Atkinson says about 400 workers have been directly affected by the closure of the Canfor mill

Orangeville Northmen take Minto Cup at Langley Events Centre

Swept best-of-five series 3-0 over Victoria Shamrocks

Expanded support to help B.C. youth from care attend university still falling short

Inadequate support, limited awareness and eligibility restrictions some of the existing challenges

Ethnic media aim to help maintain boost in voting by new Canadians

Statistics Canada says new Canadians made up about one-fifth of the voting population in 2016

UPDATE: Crown cross-examines B.C. father accused of killing daughters

Andrew Berry is charged in the deaths of six-year-old Chloe and four-year-old Aubrey in 2017

Most Read